Labour Codes: What Changes for Workers and Employers?
Table of Contents
Source: The Indian Express, PIB
Relevance: Facts for Prelims, GS-II (Polity & Governance – Labour laws, Welfare), GS-III (Growth, Employment, Ease of Doing Business)
Key Concepts for Prelims and Mains:
For Prelims:
Four Labour Codes, National Floor Wage, Fixed-term employment, EPFO & ESIC threshold changes, Definition of worker, strike, mass casual leave.For Mains:
Rationale for codification of 29 labour laws into 4 codes, Impact on workers’ rights (social security, job security, right to strike), Impact on employers (compliance burden, ease of doing business, FDI), Issues of informal/unorganised sector & gig workers, Labour reforms vs. concerns of trade unions (hire & fire, retrenchment norms)
Why in News?
- With effect from 21 November 2025, the Union Government has begun implementing the four Labour Codes, which were passed by Parliament earlier to replace 29 Central labour laws.
- Objective:
- Simplify and rationalise labour laws
- Ensure uniform wage structure and social security
- Reduce compliance burden and improve ease of doing business
- However, trade unions have raised concerns regarding:
- Hire-and-fire flexibility
- Retrenchment and closure norms
- Fixed-term employment
- Restrictions on right to strike
Background / Present Status
- Pre-reform regime: 29 Central labour laws were fragmented and overlapping, many framed during colonial / early post-Independence era.
- Problems:
- Multiple definitions of “worker”, “wages”, etc.
- Heavy compliance burden (multiple registrations, returns, inspections)
- Limited, non-uniform social security coverage, esp. for unorganised workers.
- Labour is in the Concurrent List, so Centre & States both legislate. This led to a patchwork of laws and confusion for employers operating across states.
- Reform idea: Consolidate laws into 4 comprehensive codes to ensure clarity, uniformity, and flexibility.
Constitutional / Legal Provisions
- Entry 22–24, 35, Concurrent List (List III) – Trade unions, industrial disputes, labour welfare, etc.
- Four Codes:
- Code on Wages, 2019 – replaces 4 laws on wages & bonus.
- Code on Social Security, 2020 – merges 9 laws (EPF, ESI, gratuity, maternity benefit, etc.).
- Industrial Relations Code, 2020 – merges 3 laws (Trade Unions, Industrial Disputes, Industrial Employment).
- OSH Code, 2020 – merges 13 laws on factories, mines, contract labour, etc.
Key Provisions / Changes – Code-wise
1. Code on Wages
a) Consolidation & Coverage
- Merges 4 laws related to wages and bonus.
- Applies to all employees, irrespective of:
- sector (organised/unorganised)
- wage level
- type of industry or gender
- Earlier, minimum wage provisions were limited to scheduled employment and employees below a certain income (e.g., ₹24,000/month).
b) National Floor Wage
- Introduces a National Floor Wage as baseline – all States must fix minimum wages not below this.
- Aims to reduce inter-State disparity & wage exploitation.
c) Definition of “Wage”
- Wage = Basic Pay + Dearness Allowance + Retaining Allowance.
- This becomes the basis for social security contributions & other benefits.
- Deductions cannot exceed 50% of total pay.
d) Working Hours & Overtime
- Working hours: 8–12 hours/day, but total weekly hours cannot exceed 48 hours.
- Overtime: at least 2 times the normal wage for work beyond normal hours.
e) Timely Payment & Wage Slips
- Clear time limits for wage payment:
- Daily – end of shift
- Weekly – before weekly holiday
- Fortnightly – within 2 days of end of fortnight
- Monthly – within 7 days of next month
- On resignation/termination – within 2 days
- Mandatory wage slips (physical or electronic) for all employees – documentary proof of:
- wages, allowances, deductions, net pay
2. Code on Social Security
a) Consolidation & Coverage
- Merges 9 existing social security laws – EPF, ESI, gratuity, maternity benefit, etc.
- Extends coverage to both organised and unorganised sectors.
b) Gig & Platform Workers
- For the first time, defines gig workers and platform workers legally.
- Provides for:
- National registration of such workers;
- Creation of a Social Security Fund for them.
c) Funding Mechanism
- Social security schemes may be funded by:
- Union & State Governments;
- Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) contributions;
- Aggregators (for gig workers) contributing 1–2% of annual turnover, capped at 5% of the amount payable to gig workers.
d) Gratuity & Fixed-Term Workers
- Fixed-term employees (contractual for specific time) will:
- Be treated at par with permanent workers in terms of wages & benefits;
- Become eligible for gratuity after 1 year of continuous service
- (Earlier: only permanent employees after 5 years).
e) EPFO & ESIC Expansion
- EPFO coverage: all establishments with 20+ employees, irrespective of type of industry.
- ESIC coverage:
- Pan-India, not limited to notified areas;
- Mandatory even if 1 worker is engaged in hazardous occupation (earlier minimum 10 workers);
- Plantation owners can now opt in voluntarily;
- Family definition for female employees can include parents-in-law (subject to income cap).
f) Inspector-cum-Facilitator
- Traditional “inspectors” replaced with inspector-cum-facilitators.
- Inspection scheme may include web-based inspections and electronic calling of information to reduce harassment & corruption.
3. Industrial Relations Code
a) Definition of Worker
- Defines “worker” as any person (except apprentice) employed in any industry for:
- manual, unskilled, skilled, technical, operational, clerical, supervisory work,
- includes sales promotion employees, working journalists
- includes supervisory staff earning less than ₹18,000/month.
b) Fixed-Term Employment
- Introduces fixed-term employment formally:
- Allows hiring for short, seasonal, or project-based durations.
- Workers must receive pro-rata benefits equivalent to permanent workers.
- Trade unions fear it may increase precarity & hire-and-fire culture.
c) Retrenchment, Layoff & Closure Threshold
- Earlier: factories, mines, plantations needed government permission for layoff/retrenchment/closure if 100+ workers.
- Now: threshold raised to 300 workers.
- Industry’s view: gives flexibility & encourages investment.
- Unions’ view: makes it easier to hire & fire, reduces job security.
d) Right to Strike – Stricter Conditions
- Earlier, strict notice rules applied mainly to public utility services (water, electricity, gas, etc.).
- Now, similar conditions apply to all industrial establishments:
- Workers cannot strike without:
- giving notice within 60 days before striking; and
- not striking within 14 days of giving such notice.
- Workers cannot strike without:
- Mass casual leave by more than 50% workers on a given day = deemed a strike.
- Government justifies this as preventing flash strikes.
- Trade unions say it dilutes collective bargaining power.
e) Negotiating Union / Negotiating Council
- Establishes a sole negotiating union if one union has 51% membership.
- If multiple unions exist:
- a negotiating council will have representatives of unions with at least 20% membership, with one seat per 20%.
- Aim: streamline bargaining; unions argue it weakens smaller unions.
4. OSH (Occupational Safety, Health & Working Conditions) Code
a) Consolidation & Scope
- Merges 13 Central laws relating to factories, mines, contract labour, building & construction, etc.
- Government promises:
- Single registration,
- Common licences,
- Electronic filings,
- Reduced duplication in compliance.
b) Factory Licence Threshold
- For manufacturing with power: raised from 10 to 20 workers.
- For manufacturing without power: raised from 20 to 40 workers.
- Reduces regulatory burden on very small units, but may leave some workers outside stricter safety norms.
c) Contract Labour
- Contract labour provisions now apply only when the contractor employs 50 or more workers (earlier 20).
- Defines core and non-core activities (sanitation, catering, etc.).
- Allows even core activities to be outsourced to contract labour, subject to conditions – unions fear increased casualisation.
d) Women’s Night Work & Safety
- Permits women to work before 6 am and after 7 pm, subject to:
- their consent, and
- adequate safety measures.
- Seen as enhancing gender equality but also raises safety and implementation concerns.
e) Inter-State Migrant Workers
- Definition expanded to include workers employed directly by employer, not just through contractors.
- Aims to better protect migrant workers, especially after COVID-like crises highlighted their vulnerability.
f) Appointment Letters & Health Checks
- Mandatory appointment letters for every employee – crucial for casual/informal workers who lacked written contracts earlier.
- Employers must provide annual free health examinations.
- Establishments with:
- ≥ 500 factory workers,
- ≥ 250 construction workers,
- ≥ 100 mine workers must set up Safety Committees with employer & worker representatives.
Why Workers Need These Codes (Government’s Rationale)
- Existing laws were fragmented, outdated, often not relevant for modern gig/platform economy.
- A large part of the workforce is informal and lacked:
- formal recognition
- social security
- legal protection
- Codes promise:
- Uniform social security framework across India;
- Better coverage for unorganised, gig & platform workers;
- Stricter norms on timely payment of wages, overtime, safety, written contracts, and health checks.
Why Employers Need Them
- Multiple overlapping laws created:
- high compliance costs
- “Inspector raj” & corruption
- uncertainty and litigation
- Codes aim to:
- Simplify & digitise compliance (single registration, common returns, web-based inspection);
- Provide flexibility in hiring (fixed-term employment, higher threshold for retrenchment approvals);
- Encourage FDI & formalisation by creating a predictable labour framework.
Concerns & Criticisms
Trade Unions’ Concerns:
- Raising threshold from 100 to 300 workers for layoff/closure approvals weakens job security.
- Fixed-term employment may increase contractualisation and reduce long-term stability.
- Stricter strike conditions + mass casual leave being treated as strike curtails right to protest.
- Expanded scope for contract labour in core activities may reduce permanent jobs.
Implementation Challenges:
- Many provisions need detailed rules by Centre & States – risk of delay / uneven implementation.
- Capacity constraints in ESIC/EPFO to handle expanded coverage.
- Gig & informal workers’ registration and actual access to schemes remains a big task.
Federalism Issues:
- States must realign their laws & rules with Central Codes – risk of political contestation.
Way Forward
- Balanced Approach – Ensure that ease of doing business does not come at the cost of eroding fundamental labour protections.
- Strong Social Security Net – Fast-track implementation of schemes for gig/unorganised workers with transparent funding & tech-enabled registration.
- Consultative Rule-making – Involve trade unions, employers’ bodies, and States while framing rules under the codes.
- Capacity Building – Strengthen ESIC, EPFO, labour departments, inspector-cum-facilitators with digital tools and manpower.
- Awareness & Legal Aid – Educate workers, especially in informal sectors, on new rights (wage slips, appointment letters, safety committees).
- Periodic Review – Set up mechanisms to review impact of thresholds (300 workers), fixed-term employment, and contract labour on job security.
UPSC PYQ
Q. Which one of the following Labour Codes notified by the Government of India consolidates provisions of Central labour laws such as the Factories Act, 1948 and the Plantations Labour Act, 1951, and focuses on workplace safety, health and working conditions? CDS-II (2022)
(a) The Industrial Relations Code, 2020
(b) The Code on Wages, 2019
(c) The Code on Social Security, 2020
(d) The Occupational Safety, Health and Working Conditions Code, 2020
Answer: (d) The Occupational Safety, Health and Working Conditions Code, 2020
CARE MCQ
Q. Which of the following features is/are correctly matched with the respective Labour Code?
- Recognition of gig and platform workers — Code on Social Security
- National Floor Wage — Industrial Relations Code
- Gratuity eligibility after 1 year for fixed-term workers — Code on Social Security
- Mass casual leave considered as strike — OSH Code
Options:
A. 1 and 3 only
B. 1, 2 and 4 only
C. 1, 3 and 4 only
D. 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer: A
Explanation:
- 1 ✔ Code on Social Security
- 2 ✘ National Floor Wage is under Code on Wages
- 3 ✔ Gratuity after 1 year for fixed-term workers
- 4 ✘ Mass casual leave counted as strike is under Industrial Relations Code