UPSC CARE Mains Practice 29th September 2025

UPSC CARE Mains Practice 29th September 2025

UPSC CARE Mains Practice 29th September 2025

UPSC CARE Mains Practice 29th September 2025

UPSC CARE Mains Practice 29th September 2025

UPSC CARE Mains Practice 29th September 2025

UPSC CARE Mains Practice 29th September 2025

hhUPSC CARE Mains Practice 29th September 2025hhhhhhhh

UPSC CARE Mains Practice 29th September 2025

UPSC CARE Mains Practice 29th September 2025

UPSC CARE Mains Practice 29th September 2025

UPSC CARE Mains Practice 29th September 2025

UPSC CARE Mains Practice 29th September 2025

UPSC CARE Mains Practice 29th September 2025

UPSC CARE Mains Practice 29th September 2025

UPSC CARE Mains Practice 29th September 2025

Topic – Centre-State Financial Relations

Q 2. Analysing Indian States’ macro-fiscal health: Discuss the evolving fiscal trajectories of Indian States in recent decades. How can institutions like the Finance Commission, GST Council, NITI Aayog, and RBI strengthen fiscal sustainability while balancing welfare commitments? (15 marks, 250 words)

Introduction

The fiscal health of Indian States is a cornerstone of India’s economic governance. States not only spend more than the Union on welfare but also shape the quality of health, education, and infrastructure delivery. While reforms and buoyant revenues in the 2010s strengthened State finances, the COVID-19 pandemic revealed structural weaknesses: overdependence on transfers, volatile revenue bases, and rising debt burdens. Institutional interventions—by the Finance Commission, GST Council, NITI Aayog, and RBI—are critical in navigating these challenges.

Body

  • Evolution of States’ Fiscal Health
  • Uneven Revenue Capacity and Vertical Imbalances
  • Rising Borrowings and Debt Stress
  • The Welfare Paradox
  • Institutional Interventions for Fiscal Sustainability

Conclusion

Indian States face a dual challenge—meeting developmental aspirations while maintaining fiscal sustainability. Institutional mechanisms—the Finance Commission, GST Council, NITI Aayog, and RBI—must act in concert to strengthen fiscal autonomy, improve expenditure quality, and enforce discipline. A cooperative federal framework with transparent fiscal practices will ensure that welfare commitments rest on sustainable revenues rather than fragile borrowings.

UPSC Syllabus

Centre-State Financial Relations

Why was this question asked?

Q. How have the recommendations of the 14th Finance Commission of India enabled the States to improve their fiscal position? (2021)

Introduction

The fiscal health of Indian States is a cornerstone of India’s economic governance. States not only spend more than the Union on welfare but also shape the quality of health, education, and infrastructure delivery. While reforms and buoyant revenues in the 2010s strengthened State finances, the COVID-19 pandemic revealed structural weaknesses: overdependence on transfers, volatile revenue bases, and rising debt burdens. Institutional interventions—by the Finance Commission, GST Council, NITI Aayog, and RBI—are critical in navigating these challenges.

Body

Evolution of States’ Fiscal Health

  • In the 2000s, deficits were chronic; reforms like VAT and improved tax administration improved finances in the 2010s.
  • Some States reported revenue surpluses (e.g., Gujarat, Maharashtra, Uttar Pradesh in 2022–23).
  • Pandemic shocks reversed this: revenues fell while expenditures surged, forcing widespread borrowing.

Uneven Revenue Capacity and Vertical Imbalances

  • Maharashtra mobilises ~70% of receipts internally; Arunachal Pradesh only ~9%.
  • Uttar Pradesh generated only 42% of receipts on its own despite showing surplus, highlighting vertical imbalances.
  • States’ non-tax revenues are fragile: Kerala’s lotteries (~₹12,000 crore), Odisha’s mining royalties, Telangana’s land sales. These are one-time or volatile streams.
  • Here, Finance Commission transfers and GST devolution remain lifelines for poorer States.

Rising Borrowings and Debt Stress

  • Andhra Pradesh tripled borrowings to ₹1.86 lakh crore; Rajasthan quadrupled to ₹1.6 lakh crore by 2022–23.
  • Debt–GSDP ratios remain alarming in Punjab (45%), Himachal Pradesh (48%), and Bihar (39%).
  • Comparatively, Odisha (15%) and Gujarat (~20%) showcase better debt management.
  • The RBI’s annual “State Finances: A Study of Budgets” has warned of hidden liabilities and off-budget borrowings, especially in States offering farm loan waivers and power subsidies.

The Welfare Paradox

  • Revenue surpluses often mask under-investment in welfare or reliance on central transfers.
  • Populist schemes like free power (Andhra Pradesh, Punjab) or farm waivers defer fiscal burdens via guarantees/SPVs.
  • NITI Aayog’s State Health Index and SDG Index reveal that surpluses don’t always translate into better social outcomes.
  • The paradox: a vast welfare state rests on a thin and fragile fiscal base, with risks of unsustainable debt.

Institutional Interventions for Fiscal Sustainability

  • Finance Commission: The 15th Finance Commission allocated 41% of divisible pool to States; future Commissions must link grants with fiscal responsibility and capital spending.
  • GST Council: Needs to expand tax base, rationalise slabs, and ensure predictable transfers to reduce compensation dependence.
  • NITI Aayog: Its indices can be tied to fiscal incentives, nudging States to prioritise quality expenditure over populism.
  • RBI Oversight: State-level Debt Management Cells under RBI guidance could monitor contingent liabilities and hidden borrowings.
  • FRBM & Fiscal Councils: Updating State-level FRBM Acts with escape clauses and setting up independent Fiscal Councils can ensure transparency and discipline.

Conclusion

Indian States face a dual challenge—meeting developmental aspirations while maintaining fiscal sustainability. Institutional mechanisms—the Finance Commission, GST Council, NITI Aayog, and RBI—must act in concert to strengthen fiscal autonomy, improve expenditure quality, and enforce discipline. A cooperative federal framework with transparent fiscal practices will ensure that welfare commitments rest on sustainable revenues rather than fragile borrowings.

Topic – Noise Pollution in India

Q 2. Why should Indians care about noise pollution in cities? Examine the health, social, and governance challenges posed by urban noise, and suggest a multi-pronged strategy for mitigation. (15 marks, 250 words)

Introduction

Noise pollution, though often treated as a peripheral nuisance, has emerged as a significant urban health and governance challenge in India. Legally, it is recognized as an air pollutant under the Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981. Medically, excessive noise contributes to hypertension, stress disorders, sleep disruption, and cognitive decline. Yet, despite its serious implications, systematic monitoring and policy attention remain inadequate, making it a silent but severe crisis in Indian cities.

Body

  • Health Implications of Noise Pollution
  • Systemic and Governance Failures
  • Social and Equity Dimensions
  • Policy and Urban Planning Gaps
  • Way Forward: Multi-Pronged Strategy

Conclusion

Noise pollution in Indian cities is no longer a minor irritant but a public health and social justice crisis. By treating noise with the seriousness accorded to air and water pollution — through robust monitoring, integrated governance, and inclusive urban planning — India can reclaim the right to quiet as a basic condition of well-being. The lesson from air pollution is clear: neglect amplifies harm; proactive action can save lives and make cities healthier and more equitable.

UPSC Syllabus

Noise Pollution in India

Why was this question asked?

Q. Enumerate the National Water Policy of India. Taking river Ganges as an example, discuss the strategies which may be adopted for river water pollution control and management. What are the legal provisions of management and handling of hazardous wastes in India? [2013]

Introduction

Noise pollution, though often treated as a peripheral nuisance, has emerged as a significant urban health and governance challenge in India. Legally, it is recognized as an air pollutant under the Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981. Medically, excessive noise contributes to hypertension, stress disorders, sleep disruption, and cognitive decline. Yet, despite its serious implications, systematic monitoring and policy attention remain inadequate, making it a silent but severe crisis in Indian cities.

Body

Health Implications of Noise Pollution

  • The World Health Organization (WHO) prescribes safe residential daytime exposure at 55 dB(A), while India’s Noise Rules, 2000, set 55 dB for day and 45 dB at night.
  • However, Indian traffic corridors often exceed 70 dB(A), exposing millions to unsafe levels.
  • Chronic exposure is linked to cardiovascular diseases, stress, reduced work efficiency, impaired learning in children, and premature mortality.
  • Vulnerable groups — street vendors, traffic police, construction workers, and slum residents — face the harshest impacts due to occupational and residential exposure.

Systemic and Governance Failures

  • Sparse monitoring: Unlike air pollution, India lacks real-time noise mapping; data remains sporadic and reactive.
  • Fragmented jurisdiction: Pollution control boards, municipal bodies, and police share responsibility but lack coordination.
  • Weak enforcement: Cultural tolerance of loud practices (honking, firecrackers, loudspeakers) and limited punitive measures reduce deterrence.
  • Symbolic interventions such as temporary honking bans during festivals fail to address structural drivers.

Social and Equity Dimensions

  • The burden is inequitably distributed: the poor and informal workers live and work in the noisiest environments.
  • Wealthier citizens can afford soundproofing, quieter neighborhoods, or private vehicles, while vulnerable groups face daily exposure.
  • Educational institutions and hospitals near high-noise zones suffer from reduced quality of learning and care, reinforcing cycles of disadvantage.

Policy and Urban Planning Gaps

  • Urban planning rarely integrates noise considerations into zoning, land use, or transport design.
  • Green buffers such as trees, parks, and noise barriers are underutilized despite their proven effectiveness.
  • Transport policies prioritize vehicular growth over quiet mobility options like cycling, walking, and electric vehicles.
  • Health surveys and epidemiological studies seldom track noise exposure systematically, leaving policymakers blind to its full impact.

Way Forward: Multi-Pronged Strategy

  • Strengthen monitoring: Deploy low-cost sensors and machine-learning tools to map real-time soundscapes.
  • Integrated governance: Create dedicated noise management units bringing together municipalities, pollution boards, and traffic police.
  • Urban design solutions: Promote zoning reforms, build green buffers, and incentivize quieter public transport fleets.
  • Legal and enforcement reforms: Enforce Noise Pollution Rules, 2000 with clear penalties, and mandate noise audits for construction and industries.
  • Community engagement: Conduct awareness campaigns, collaborate with religious/community leaders, and promote cultural shifts toward quieter celebrations.
  • Equity focus: Prioritize schools, hospitals, and informal settlements in mitigation efforts to ensure the right to quiet is universal.

Conclusion

Noise pollution in Indian cities is no longer a minor irritant but a public health and social justice crisis. By treating noise with the seriousness accorded to air and water pollution — through robust monitoring, integrated governance, and inclusive urban planning — India can reclaim the right to quiet as a basic condition of well-being. The lesson from air pollution is clear: neglect amplifies harm; proactive action can save lives and make cities healthier and more equitable.

UPSC CARE Mains Practice 30th September 2025
UPSC CARE Mains Practice 26th September 2025

Enroll Now for Unlimited UPSC Utsav

Start Date

22/03/2026

Timings

08 AM – 4 PM

    Courses

    Scroll to Top