UPSC CARE Mains Practice 26th March 2026
Mains Practice Questions for the Day
- The decline in winter snowfall in the Himalayan region reflects deeper climate change impacts. Examine its implications for water security, agriculture, and regional ecology. Suggest suitable adaptation measures.
- The ongoing disruptions in West Asia have exposed structural weaknesses in India’s gas-based energy ecosystem. Critically examine how the differential vulnerabilities of LPG and LNG supply chains have shaped India’s policy push towards Piped Natural Gas (PNG). Discuss the economic, infrastructural, geopolitical, and social dimensions of this transition.
Q.The decline in winter snowfall in the Himalayan region reflects deeper climate change impacts. Examine its implications for water security, agriculture, and regional ecology. Suggest suitable adaptation measures.
Introduction:
The Himalayan region, particularly Kashmir Valley, is experiencing a steady decline in winter snowfall due to changing climatic conditions. Snowfall in this region, largely influenced by Western Disturbances, acts as a natural water reservoir. Its reduction reflects a broader warming trend across the Himalayas and signals significant environmental stress.
Body
Implications on Water Security
Snow accumulation in the Himalayan region functions as a natural storage system that releases water gradually during warmer months. A decline in snowfall weakens this mechanism, resulting in reduced river flows and early drying of streams. Rivers such as the Jhelum show diminished discharge levels, which directly affects irrigation and drinking water availability. This leads to seasonal water scarcity, especially during the summer months when demand is highest.
Implications on Agriculture and Horticulture
Agriculture in the region is highly dependent on snowmelt for irrigation. Reduced snowfall disrupts this cycle, causing water stress during critical crop growth stages. Field crops such as wheat and mustard experience lower productivity due to insufficient moisture and altered temperature conditions. The horticulture sector, which forms the backbone of the rural economy, is particularly vulnerable. Fruit crops like apples, cherries, and walnuts require a specific number of chilling hours during winter. Warmer winters fail to meet these requirements, leading to delayed flowering, poor fruit set, and reduced yield and quality
Ecological Consequences
The decline in snowfall alters the ecological balance of the region. Many plant and animal species depend on prolonged cold conditions for survival. Warmer winters may lead to the disappearance of cold-adapted species and the emergence of new invasive species. Reduced snow persistence also affects groundwater recharge, wetland systems, and local microclimates. Additionally, pests and pathogens that are normally controlled by cold temperatures tend to survive and multiply, increasing ecological stress
Economic and Livelihood Impacts
Tourism, particularly winter tourism activities such as skiing in Gulmarg, is adversely affected by declining snowfall. Reduced tourist inflow impacts local livelihoods and regional revenue. Farmers face increased costs due to higher dependence on irrigation and pesticides, thereby affecting economic stability in rural areas.
Causes of Declining Snowfall
The primary cause is the rising temperature trend observed across the Himalayan region. Scientific observations indicate a steady increase in average temperatures over recent decades. Additionally, the erratic behaviour of Western Disturbances has reduced consistent winter precipitation. Rapid urbanisation, increased infrastructure development, and human activities have further intensified local climatic changes.
Challenges in Policy Response
Despite clear signs of climatic shifts, policy responses remain inadequate. Existing climate action plans focus largely on long-term strategies and fail to address immediate seasonal variations. There is also a lack of coordination among sectors such as water management, agriculture, and tourism. The absence of contingency planning further aggravates vulnerability to sudden climatic changes.
Adaptation Measures and Way Forward
Effective adaptation requires strengthening water conservation practices such as rainwater harvesting, groundwater recharge, and protection of catchment areas. Innovative solutions like artificial glaciers and seasonal water storage systems can help regulate water availability. Sustainable urban planning should ensure adequate infiltration zones and reduce excessive surface runoff. A comprehensive and integrated policy approach linking climate action with agriculture, water management, and tourism is essential for building long-term resilience.
Conclusion:
The decline in winter snowfall in the Himalayas is a clear indicator of ongoing climate change. It has far-reaching implications for water security, agriculture, ecology, and livelihoods. Addressing this challenge requires immediate, coordinated, and adaptive strategies to ensure sustainable development and ecological balance in the region.
Q. The ongoing disruptions in West Asia have exposed structural weaknesses in India’s gas-based energy ecosystem. Critically examine how the differential vulnerabilities of LPG and LNG supply chains have shaped India’s policy push towards Piped Natural Gas (PNG). Discuss the economic, infrastructural, geopolitical, and social dimensions of this transition.
(GS Paper II – Polity and Governance)
Introduction:
The disruption of energy flows through the Strait of Hormuz during the West Asia crisis has highlighted India’s acute dependence on imported LPG and LNG. With nearly 54% of LPG and about 30% of natural gas supplies affected, the government’s push towards PNG reflects a structural response to external energy shocks.
Body
1. Structural Vulnerabilities in LPG and LNG Systems
- LPG Dependence: ~60% import dependence; ~90% routed via Hormuz → high chokepoint risk.
- Logistical Fragility: Cylinder-based supply chain (transport, bottling, storage) prone to disruption.
- LNG Constraints: Though relatively diversified, still dependent on maritime transport and regasification infrastructure.
- Demand Pressure: Large domestic base (33+ crore LPG connections) amplifies vulnerability.
2. Why PNG is Being Promoted: A Structural Shift
(a) Infrastructural Dimension
- Pipeline-based delivery reduces dependence on physical logistics.
- Enables integration of multiple gas sources (domestic + global LNG terminals).
(b) Economic Dimension
- Lower end-user cost (elimination of intermediaries).
- Reduction in LPG subsidy burden and fiscal stress.
(c) Geopolitical Dimension
- Minimises exposure to chokepoints like Hormuz.
- Facilitates diversification (USA, Australia, Russia, Mozambique).
(d) Environmental Dimension
- Cleaner fuel compared to LPG, coal, and biomass.
(e) Governance Dimension
- Push for a unified national pipeline framework and faster clearances.
3. Critical Limitations of the PNG Transition
- Infrastructure Deficit: Only ~1.5 crore PNG users vs 33+ crore LPG users.
- Capital and Time Intensive: Nationwide pipeline grid requires long-term investment.
- Rural Exclusion: Pipeline economics unviable in dispersed settlements.
- Continued Import Dependence: LNG imports still required → vulnerability not eliminated.
- Operational Risks: Urban implementation challenges (land, permissions, coordination).
4. Broader Implications
- Energy Transition Strategy: Shift from fuel-based to network-based energy systems.
- Demand Rationalisation: Prioritisation of households and essential sectors.
- Industrial Impact: Curtailment for commercial users indicates supply stress.
Conclusion:
The LPG-to-PNG transition represents a deeper structural reform aimed at reducing India’s exposure to external energy shocks. However, unless complemented by domestic production, diversified imports, and inclusive infrastructure expansion, PNG will remain a partial solution rather than a comprehensive answer to India’s energy security challenge.



